| join now | shop | freebies & contests | help
     gURL.com  the Web    web search powered by Yahoo!


SHOUT OUT BOARDS

YOUR ROOM


HELP ME HEATHER

SEX ED BLOG



gURL GAMES

QUIZZES



COMIX

PHOTOS



POLLS

VIDEO



BODY IMAGE

SEX

  you are here  >>> REACT > dig or dis > music  
  related topics  >>>  music, movies & media    

 
   you are here: MUSIC
   
punk rock

what do you think?
dig it or dis it
456
Digs

a reply to a dis
alrite, u really cant label punk. Simple Plan is punk. They may not be 100% punk, but they are punk. u cant go around sayin who's punk and who's not, labeling people or bands u dont even kno. every1 haz a different opinion about whtz punk and whts not, so i'd advise u to respect other peoples opinions and not to go dissin avril or SP or any other bands. Just because a band doesnt wear eyeliner or have tattoos doesnt mean anything. all bands are differnt in their own way, and their music may all be different. Some bands u think are "punk" sing about stuff other bands also sing about.
--Posted by caitlynrx



shut it ppl
green day pratically re envented the punk rock scene.juss b/c they or any other band sound differently than the typical "punk rock" band dosent give any1 the rght 2 dis them.And gc,sp,and other bands u idiots have mentioned dont even consider themselves punk they just want 2 get their music heard and fyi juss b/c u've heard about the sex pistols,the clash,etc doesnt mean ur more punk it just means uve picked up a magizine or turned on mtv here lately.it doesnt matter if they r punk,if u like it listen 2 it.btw if u like my chemical romance try listening to silverstein,from first to last,or the starting line,they r all really good.
--Posted by imnotokay24




i luv it
i don't consider myself a punk just bcus i listen 2 it but i really luv it it rox!!!!!!!
--Posted by maxichic




it's cool...
I think punk rock is alright...I mean, I am not obsessed with it. But all I am saying is that it's cool. I mean people have their freedom of speech, especially when it comes to music.
--Posted by bohogoddess




Punk
Sex Pistols, The Clash, The Ramones, NOFX, Bad Religion, Anti-Flag..the list could go on. Older punk bands are better then they are now. Take a look at The Ramones and Good Charlotte. Hear the diffrence in music...see the diffrent style. Take The Sex Pistols and Simple Plan..see the ***ing goddamn diffrence. Avril ***ing Lavgine and Blondie...*** see the diffrence now. Good Charlotte, Simple Plan, Avril Lavinge are NOT punk rock. They're pretty much pop. Yeah sure I listen to Good Charlotte, I admit it..but I don't call them punk, they're pop(I like a lot of diffrent genre's...GC is the only pop I really like...Eminem is the only rapper I like). But take a look at 70's punk bands and the ones today.
--Posted by emo_child




the killers!!!!
i am the biggest killers fan and any one who thinks punk rock is bad than they are stupidoS!!!you cant beat the killers the Clash the Bravery,GC or any one!!1
--Posted by ksaw130




mm depends...
ppl think of different things when they hear "punk rock" and people will argue nonstop about who is and isn't punk, in my opinion punk rock is originality, doing it your way not giving a shit about anything. Now any band that comes out with dyed hair, make up, and the stereotypical punk fashion is labeled "punk" ..but you really have to listen to the music...what i call "punk rock" tho...I couldnt live without..
--Posted by antiauthority90



right...
punk=cool punk=the clash etc punk DOES NOT= green day good charlotte. greenday is a v good band but theyre not makers of punk music- theyre makers of rock music. good charlotte suck. they make poprock- aka mockrock- other makers of mockrock include avril titface lavigne, busted and mcfly.
--Posted by alissi



Punk Rock ROCKS!
OH YAH BABEY!! I LOVE IT, LOVE IT, LOVE IT!!! (Hedley, Green Day, The Used, Yellowcard, My Chemical Romance, The Killers, The Ramones, Me First and The Gimme Gimmes, etc...) Remember kids listen to Punk, Rock or Metal Music..its the way to go! :P PS. Dont Mosh With Sharp or Pointy Objects!
--Posted by darkprincess333




I LOVE IT !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
its the best sh*t EVER! i love the ramones, blackflag, the clash and of course RANCID!!!!
--Posted by darkfairy88




I <3 SIMPLE PLAN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
SIMPLE PLAN IS THE SHIZ!!!!!!! LO LI <3 SEBASTIEN THE MOST!!! ROCK ON INVASION CREW MEMBERS!!
--Posted by PierreFreak11




I'M DIGGIN' IT!
Punk is different things to different people. Nobody's really a "punk expert".
--Posted by iplay_airguitar




POSERS
Ok so like you have somthing wrong with your head if you think that Simple Plan & Good Charlotte are punk. Its the good bands like the sex pistols. the ramones. anti flag. not those good for nothing poser wannabes. YER?!//
--Posted by stop_moshn_roll




gets me up
punk rocks! no literally! it dus, it gets me through the day, lets me know there are ppl out there that feel the same way as i do, wat they say in there songs are all true, i can relate to them. especially good charlotte its like my own therapy all of u ppl who think punk is dead its not! its still here and its forever stop dissin it and it leave it to the ppl that actually know how to diss. gees!
--Posted by joelsbabe



Real punk vs poser punk vs unknown genres.
Okay, there's the real punk. And the poser punk shit. Like Avril. And then there's the bands that ALOT of people think are PUNK posers, when they actually belong in another genre. Alot of people hear some indie or emo and they immediatly think they're punk posers, because they think that they're trying to sound punk, when they're not. That ***ing sucks. I like real punk. Not the poser punk crap. And I like indie and emo too. Instead of going "OMGMGOGMOG POSRZZZ!!!! I H8 DEM SOOOO MUCH!!!112" Just ignore them, and just listen to what you want to listen to.
--Posted by mjauzi



106
Disses

wannabes
people these days dont know wut punk is..they think punk is a fashion and consider bands like blink 182 and good charlotte punk..***in losers most of these people probably have never heard of the sex pistols, the ramones, pennywise, rancid or real punk bands...ignorant mother***ers
--Posted by kinky-mischief



The old punk rock bands are better
Today's punk is stupid... Wow I hate Green Day..
--Posted by rammstein66




EVERYONE WHO "DIGS" IT NEEDS TO LEARN WHAT BANDS ARE PUNK AND WHAT BANDS ARENT
most of the people in this column think Green Day is punk, and they are sadly mistaken. they are pop punk, the mainstream stuff. Real punk are bands like the Misfits, the Ramones, Minor Threat, Bad Religion, Germ, The Velvet Underground and Nico, the Distillers, The Exploited, The Casulties. not My Chemical Romance, Yellowcard, and The Killers, get a ***ing clue.
--Posted by ohohairplane



Nobody knows what it is anymore.
Green. Day. Is. Not. Punk. If another person says they are or how supposedly hot Billie Joe is (he's really goddamned ugly) I'll bite their head off. The bands that were part of the late 70s scene, either in the UK with The Clash and the Sex Pistols, or the New York/CBGB scene with The Ramones or possibly even Blondie and the Talking Heads...those are punk. Not any stupid whiny emo band of today.
--Posted by carscat




WHAT THE F**K
I think punk bands are stupid they have no meaning can you understand what they are saying cuz i cant its just a lame excuse to scream and yell in a mike i think the only music worse than punk rock is heavy metal i mean that from the bottom of my heart hip-hop and rap are 2 types of music thay have meaning and feeling i hope i dont affend anyone
--Posted by shortie40




umm
well theres posers and the none posers!! its about poliyics and music! not about the clothes... im not punk rock at all! my ex is though! and well ive learned to tell the reals ones w/ the fake ones..
--Posted by imhereforyou318



umm
well theres posers and the none posers!! its about politics and music! not about the clothes... im not punk rock at all! my ex is though! and well ive learned to tell the reals ones w/ the fake ones..
--Posted by imhereforyou318





People don't get punk at all I mean if it comes on the radio and its not classic punk like the Ramones then it isn't punk its pop rock.
--Posted by xxmeowxmixx




What's the point?
I adore bands like Fear and the Misfits, but almost everyone needs to own up to liking at least one Green Day song. I'm not saying it's punk, but it takes you back a ways. Anyway, I HATE the new scene that was caused by the "new punk sound," or whatever people want to call it. These kids go to shows, act like morons, don't buy anything, then dis the bands that do things like cover Fear or Motorhead. It's come to a point where the only shows worth seeing are at parties because you can be selective of who gets in. It sucks. I don't dis the music by any means, but I'm going to have to say I dis the scene. Also, the debate about "what punk is" is absolutely ridiculous. No one will agree, no one knows for sure, and everyone has an opinion. I'll end with this: the only thing more punk rock than punk rock is never needing to define punk rock or what it stands for- that could be the least punk rock thing you could do.
--Posted by lemmysgirl



replying to a dig it
if you think wake me up when september ends is a punk song then i don't think you ever heard of the old green day....new green day is NOT punk old green day is
--Posted by iluvevan14





losers
Jesus you ppl need to learn what punk means ur retarted green day suck and so does simple plan come on nofx Halifax those are good bands I mean fall out boy is a pretty god but my god come on learn the meaning of punk plz
--Posted by i_add_emo_2_my_flair




Just...
People have forgotten it and im not going to dis bands that say theyre punk rock or bring up bands that actually are but people have just forgotten the meaning of music.
--Posted by pnkr0ckprncess



Is dead
period.
--Posted by hxctruetilldeath



Is dead
period.
--Posted by hxctruetilldeath




I hate it!!!!!!!!!!
--Posted by emmys_55



You must be a gURL member to post. Not a gURL member? Join now! (It's free!)





email this feature to a friend:
IM this feature to a friend (AIM only):
tell us what you think of this feature.

  CONNECT EXPLORE gURL.com BY TOPIC ABOUT gURL  
 
shout out boards
gURL newsletter


being yourself
beliefs
body image
brainylicious
dating
d.i.y.
fashion & style
friends & family
health
music, movies & media
school & careers
sex
sports
sucky emotions

contact us
what is gURL?
advertise on gURL
privacy policy
terms of service
help

 
  ADVERTISEMENT

   
   Also... Get your horoscope mailed to you every day!
   Sign up for gURL and Astrology.com's daily newsletter.

 

© iVillage Inc. 1995-2008. All rights reserved.